top of page

"In a world where there is so much to be done, I felt strongly impressed that there must be something for me to do."

-Dorothea Dix

     -Background: Previously, there had been problems with the way patients were treated in asylums (Brinkley, 300). The sick and insane patients were treated harshly; many were "chained, beaten with rods, [and] lashed into obedience" (Prison and Asylum Reform). In other words, patients were deemed inferior to other people and treated such. In addition, there were many issues in prisons as well (Prison and Asylum Reform). One of the biggest issues was that people were all placed together, no matter what crime they had comitted, what their age was, or even their gender (Prison and Asylum Reform). So theoretically, a middle aged murderer could be placed in the same cell as a woman who had committed a minor crime and possibly a child who was placed in there for stealing. It was situations like these that put these people in danger, and it was situations like these that made people realize something had to be done about it (Brinkley, 301).

     -Leaders Involved: One of the most influential leaders of the hospital and prison reforms was Dorothea Dix (Brinkley).  She had grown up mostly in her grandmother's care because her father was unstable (Stoddard,137). It was during the earlier years in her life while she was teaching children that she became greatly influenced by a preacher and reformer named Dr. William Ellery Channing (Stoddard, 138). Channing influenced Dix by expressing his belief that "the great end of government is to spread a shield over the rights of all" (Stoddard, 139). Around her early thirties, Dix suffered from a nervous and physical collapse due to how hard she had pushed herself in her studies and teachings (Stoddard, 139). She then spent time with Channing in England and once recovered, learned about the harsh treatment of those in asylums (Stoddard, 139).  Dorothea then went on to speak with other reformers in the U.S., such as Dr. Samuel Howe (Prison and Asylum Reform). Dr. Howe was most known for creating the first New-England Institution for the Education of the Blind (Trent). Dix later continued to around the U.S. in order to see these harsh conditions for herself (Brinkley, 300). She observed that their was a "woman who seemed to be quite sane tied in a dark stall....no one could recall why she had been put there..." (Stoddard, 141). She also recorded seeing an "old naked man with his feet frozen off, the stumps in chains" (Stoddard, 141). No wonder these people were insane and sick! In conditions like these they had no chance of improving their health whatsoever. Dix decided to make these harsh treatments known to others, so she made speeches to a legislature that began with the statement, "I come to present the strong claims of suffering humanity. I come as the advocate of helpless, forgotten, insane men and women; of beings sunk to a condition from which the unconcerned world would start with real horror" (Stoddard, 141). Her speeches to state legislatures helped lead to the establisment of five hospitals in America (Prison and Asylum Reform). She also went to Europe where she spoke about human rights to Queen Victoria and the Pope (Prison and Asylum Reform).

     

     -Democratic ideals expressed: There were many democratic ideals expressed during the advocation for prison and hospital reforms, but these ideals mainly revolved around idealism and the hope for a perfect society (Brinkley, 301). This belief of wanting to create a perfect society led citizens to think that they needed to participate in these reforms in order to strengthen the society and its citizens. Also, these reforms produced the democratic ideal of equality; the idea that all people are created equally and thus deserve to be treated humanely. Also, there seemed to be a belief in the potential of the individual that fueled the creation of new institutions to help the insane and disabled (Brinkley, 300). This belief led people to think that they had a responsiblity to care for these people who couldn't take care of themselves. Charitable activities to help these institutions and individuals also gave the sick individuals opportunities to get better, instead of being treated like animals that were far beyond help (Stoddard, 140). In conclusion, the democratic ideals used were opportunity, citizen participation, equality, and responsiblity.

     -Goals & Arguments: The main goals that reformers such as Howe and Dix had were libraries for prisoners and basic literacy such as Bible readings for prisons and asylums (Prison and Asylum Reform). They also advocated for a reduction of whippings and beatings, written legal sentences for prisoners, and the separation of women, children and the sick in both prisons and asylums (Prison and Asylum Reform).

"

     -Movement's Successes: These reform movements surprisingly influenced people in the U.S. by leading to the establishment of many asylums and prisons that treated their patients and prisoners better; these institutions were founded with more humane principles (Prison and Asylum Reform). It wasn't just the country itself that was transformed, but also reformers from Europe were greatly influenced by the U.S. (Brinkley, 301).They saw America as a model for building and improving their own institutions (Stoddard, 143). Reformers for prisoners thought that the prisoners could change and that a prison stay could have a positive effect (Prison and Hospital Reform). Another ideal that helped these reforms to be successful was the idea that the society was more responsible for criminal activity than the individuals themselves, so it was society's job to "treat the neglected children, care for the insane, and rehabilitate alcoholics" (Prison and Hospital Reform). A possible failure was that even though people eventually became involved, prisoners were not much better off. Those in asylums, however, were able to get more help due to these reformers (Prison and Asylum Reform).

     -Opinionated-Success or Failure?: I believe the only small failures were the time it took for people to actually help people in prisons and hospitals, and the fact that although prisoners recieved aid from outsiders, conditions didn't improve much (Prison and Hospital Reform). Overall, I believe the hospital and prison reforms were a success, because they stressed the importance that there are levels in society, and those that are fortunate to gain more should be able to help more in order to give back to society. Also, reformers for these institutions increased the awareness of how injust these conditions and treatments at these institutions were; an awareness that would affect future generations.

Book Sources:

  1. Stoddard, Hope. "Dorothea Dix." Famous American Women. Toronto, Canada: 
         Fitzhenry & Whiteside Limited, 1970. 136-47. Print. 

  2. Brinkley, Alan. The Empire in Transition. Sixth ed. New York: McGraw Hill, 2010. Print. 

Website Sources:

  1. "Prison and Asylum Reform." U.S. History. Independence Hall Association, 2008. 
         Web. 22 Nov. 2015. <http://www.ushistory.org/us/26d.asp>. 

  2. Trent, James. "Samuel Gridley Howe." Enyclopedia Britannica. Enyclopedia 
         Britannica, 2015. Web. 23 Nov. 2015. <http://www.britannica.com/ 
         biography/Samuel-Gridley-Howe>. 

Picture URL's:

  1. http://www.ushistory.org/us/images/00000221.jpg

  2. http://prisonandasylumreform.weebly.com/uploads/1/4/7/1/14716094/2188370.jpg?0

  3. http://www.historic-restorations.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/1851-Lunatic-Asylum.jpg

  4. http://a5.files.biography.com/image/upload/c_fit,cs_srgb,dpr_1.0,h_1200,q_80,w_1200/MTE5NTU2MzE2MzY3MzkwMjE5.jpg

  5. https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/dd/1a/65/dd1a654f0d73b5e10086b63c8a20864e.jpg

  6. http://docsouth.unc.edu/highlights/images/dix.jpg

bottom of page